Romeo and Juliet Murders (episode #5) Originally aired: Tuesday November 1, 2005 on CBS Writer: Jim Leonard Director: Lewis H. Gould Show Stars: Kimberly Elise (Maureen Dobie), Jennifer Finnigan (Annabeth Chase), John Carroll Lynch (Steve Sharpe), David Starzyk (Thom), Christian Kane (Jack Chase) All Guest Stars: Conor Dubin (Danny Robel) , Greg Zola (Oscar Hobbs), Mark Ankeny (Roger Fields), Erich Anderson (Detective George Branch), Daniel Kirschner (Medical Examiner), Nancy Lenehan (Patty), Peter Trencher (Counselor), Karly Rothenberg (Counselor #2), Jim Perry (Uncle Bill), Meagan Smith (Megan), Thom Gossom Jr. (Judge Hanophy), Alan Woolf (Judge Hillyard), Jackson Rathbone (Scott Fields), Lenora May (Nurse), Elizabeth Rice (Tracy Fields), Amy Wieczorek (Caroline) Production Code: 104

Annabeth and Maureen prosecute a case involving siblings whose parents are found murdered after they discover a secret which the teenagers had been keeping from them. Meanwhile, Maureen and Annabeth admit to each other that they sometimes think that each other's life is more desirable -- Maureen wishes she had a family to go home to, while Annabeth wishes she did not have to be responsible for anyone but herself.